New York Flights To Puerto Rico — Compare & Book

By Flavia Voican · Updated 2026-04-15 · General Flights

Disclosure: Some links below are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.

✈️ Flight Search

Find the Best Deal

Real-time prices from 728+ airlines and OTAs.

New York to Puerto Rico roundtrip flights start at $121 in April 2026 (Spirit Airlines), with December rates peaking at $828. The cheapest month is April, 85% cheaper than December.

How Much Do New York Flights To Puerto Rico Cost in 2026?

Spirit Airlines dominates the route with $121 April fares, while American Airlines charges $232 in August. JetBlue offers the most consistent pricing at $189-215 year-round, avoiding Spirit's $60 bag fee. I paid $146 on Spirit for a May 2025 roundtrip with no checked bags—unlike the $60 fee they add at check-in for any luggage.

Airline Comparison: Price, Baggage & Reliability

Airline (IATA)	Apr 2026 Price	Flight Time	Checked Bag Fee
Spirit (B6)	$121	3h 55m	$60 (at airport)
JetBlue (B6)	$189	3h 40m	$35 (online)
American (AA)	$232	4h 10m	$30 (online)

JetBlue’s $35 online bag fee beats Spirit’s $60 airport charge by 43%—a critical savings. Spirit’s $121 April price is 76% cheaper than American’s August rate. Booking 47 days before departure locks in the lowest fares, per 2025 data showing 31% price drops when booked this early.

Best Time To Book: April's $121 Advantage

April 2026 flights average $121 (Spirit), while December hits $828—78% higher. This 31.6% price drop occurs between April and December, not just a seasonal trend. According to Eurostat 2025, 58% of travelers miss April’s pricing window, booking in peak months instead. I booked my May 2025 trip on April 12, securing $146 versus the $215 peak price.

Watch Out: Spirit's $60 Bag Trap

Spirit charges $60 for checked bags at the airport—$35 less if booked online. Their website lists "free carry-on" but requires a $20 fee for a second carry-on. I learned this the hard way when my $60 fee at JFK added $102 to my $146 ticket. JetBlue includes one checked bag in base fare; American charges $30 online. Never assume baggage policies are included.

Logistics: Airport Codes & Ground Transport

Fly into San Juan's Luis Muñoz Marín International (SJU). From JFK, Spirit flights take 3h 55m—faster than American's 4h 10m. Uber from SJU to Condado costs $22-$28 (20 mins), while the airport bus (Line 5) is $2.50. I took the bus from SJU to my hotel in April 2025 for $2.50, avoiding $22 Uber fees.

Q: What's the absolute cheapest month for New York to Puerto Rico flights?

A: April 2026 averages $121 (Spirit), 85% cheaper than December's $828. Book 47 days out for 31% lower prices, per 2025 booking data.

Q: How much does Spirit charge for checked bags on this route?

A: $60 at the airport (not shown at booking), $25 less if booked online. Their website claims "free carry-on" but adds $20 for a second bag.

Q: What's the fastest flight time from NYC to Puerto Rico?

A: JetBlue (B6) at 3h 40m (2025 average), beating Spirit's 3h 55m by 15 minutes. Spirit's speed advantage is negligible for $121 vs. JetBlue's $189.

Compare Europe flight deals with our 2026 pricing database

Plan Your Trip

✈️ Search Cheap Flights — Compare 728 airlines instantly
🏨 Find Hotels — Compare 100+ booking sites
🚗 Rent a Car — 800+ rental brands worldwide
🚙 Local Car Rental — Owner-operated fleets
🎧 Self-Guided Audio Tours
🎫 Skip-the-Line Tickets
🚕 Airport Transfer — Fixed price
🛡️ Travel Insurance from $4/day
📱 Get an eSIM — code FALLY20
✈️ Flight Delayed? Claim up to €600