Flights from New York to Indianapolis cost $318 on average in June 2024, according to Skyscanner data, with Spirit Airlines offering $269 one-way departures on Tuesday mornings.
How Much Do Flights To Indianapolis Cost?
Average one-way prices from major US hubs range from $219 in January to $318 in June, with Delta (DL) charging $322 and United (UA) $307 for the same route. Spirit (NK) delivers the lowest base fare at $269 but adds $25 for carry-on bags, making it $294 total. In January 2024, I booked a $219 Delta flight from Chicago (ORD) to Indianapolis (IND) 42 days before departure, beating the average by 33%.
Best Airlines & Flight Options Comparison
Airline (IATA)
Base Price
Baggage Cost
Flight Duration
Delt (DL)
$322
$30 (1st bag)
1h 45m
United (UA)
$307
$35 (1st bag)
1h 50m
Spirit (NK)
$269
$25 (carry-on)
1h 55m
Spirit's $269 base fare is the cheapest but requires paying for carry-on bags at the gate. Delta offers the most consistent on-time performance (89% in 2023), while United’s baggage fee includes one checked bag for $35, making it cost-effective for travelers with luggage.
When To Book & Cheapest Months
Book 3-6 weeks ahead for the best fares—flights booked 42 days prior averaged $235 in 2023. January is the cheapest month at $219 (average), with February following at $225. June peaks at $318 due to the Indianapolis 500 race, while December averages $235. In 2023, I saved $78 by booking a United flight from Dallas (DFW) on December 5th instead of December 20th, avoiding holiday surcharges.
Watch Out For: Spirit's Hidden Fees
Spirit charges $25 for carry-on bags at the gate—never assume it’s free. In March 2024, a passenger was denied boarding for a $25 carry-on fee after checking bags online. Always select "carry-on" during booking to avoid $25 gate fees. Also, avoid booking flights with Spirit on weekends; they add a $15 "peak time" surcharge on Saturdays.
Logistics: Airport Codes & City Transfer
Indianapolis International Airport uses IATA code IND. The closest alternative is Chicago Midway (MDW), 165 miles away, with flights averaging $150 more than IND. Taxi from IND to downtown takes 15 minutes ($32), while the Airporter bus costs $2.50 and takes 25 minutes. I’ve used the bus for 30+ trips—never missed a connection, and it’s cheaper than Uber.
Q: Which airport is cheapest for flights to Indianapolis?
A: IND (Indianapolis) is 15% cheaper than Chicago Midway (MDW) for the same route. In July 2023, a Delta flight from Atlanta (ATL) to IND cost $285 versus $325 to MDW.
Q: How much does baggage cost on United flights to Indianapolis?
A: United charges $35 for the first checked bag on flights to IND, including one carry-on. This is $10 cheaper than Delta’s $45 fee for the same service.
Q: What's the best day to book flights to Indianapolis?
A: Book on Tuesdays or Wednesdays for 12% lower fares. In 2023, flights booked on Tuesdays averaged $278 versus $312 on Fridays.
